Mineral vs. Chemical Sunscreen: Which One Should You Be Using in 2025? 7 Tested Brands Recommendations
Sunscreen has been a non-negotiable skincare essential for decades, yet the debate between mineral and chemical sunscreens continues to spark controversy. With new research emerging and more people prioritizing clean, health-conscious beauty choices, it's time to break down the science, history, and best options available today.
Mineral vs. Chemical Sunscreens
Sunscreens work by protecting the skin from harmful ultraviolet (UV) radiation, but the way they achieve this varies.
Mineral Sunscreens (also called physical sunscreens) contain zinc oxide and/or titanium dioxide to create a physical barrier that reflects UV rays. These are typically gentler on sensitive skin and offer immediate protection upon application.
Chemical Sunscreens absorb UV radiation and convert it into heat, which is then released from the skin. Common ingredients include oxybenzone, avobenzone, octinoxate, and homosalate. While these formulas are often lightweight and blend easily into the skin, some ingredients have raised concerns about hormonal disruption and coral reef damage.
Why Is There Always A Debate?
For years, chemical sunscreens were the gold standard due to their invisible finish and ease of use. However, research has linked some chemical UV filters to endocrine disruption and environmental harm (Matta et al., 2020). In 2021, the FDA called for more data on the long-term safety of chemical filters, while Hawaii and other regions banned oxybenzone and octinoxate to protect marine ecosystems.
As of 2025, modern research leans toward mineral sunscreens as the safer, more sustainable choice, with non-nano zinc oxide being the top-recommended filter by dermatologists (Kirkland et al., 2023).
The Best Sunscreens in 2025
We reviewed sunscreens based on ingredient safety, efficacy, formulation, and user experience. Each product is rated using the CLÉCO Clean Score (CCS) out of 10, with deductions explained.
1) Best for Lightweight Wear: Boba Botanicals Daily Sheer Mineral Sunscreen Fluid SPF 50 - $24
⭐ CCS: 8/10
💡 Pros: Ultra-light texture, high SPF 50, non-toxic, reef-safe
⚠️ Deductions: May leave a slight cast on deeper skin tones, not intensely hydrating
The Daily Sheer Mineral Sunscreen Fluid SPF 50 is a weightless, fast-absorbing sunscreen that offers powerful broad-spectrum UV protection without feeling greasy or heavy. Formulated with non-nano zinc oxide, it’s reef-safe, fragrance-free, and packed with antioxidants to defend against free radicals.
Shop Bobo
2) Best for Limited Sun Exposure: Kora Organics Silky Sun Drops 100% Mineral Sunscreen Serum - $57
⭐ CCS: 9/10
💡 Pros: Lightweight serum texture, non-toxic, blends seamlessly, doubles as skincare
⚠️ Deductions: SPF could be higher, may not be hydrating enough for dry skin
The Silky Sun Drops 100% Mineral Sunscreen Serum is a game-changer for those who hate the heavy feel of traditional sunscreens. It contains 17% non-nano zinc oxide as its active ingredient. This concentration provides broad-spectrum SPF 30 protection against UVA and UVB rays. In addition to zinc oxide, the formula includes ingredients like raspberry seed oil, chia seed oil, and ectoin, which offer antioxidant benefits and support the skin's barrier function.
Does It Actually Protect?
Yes, if…
It contains enough non-nano zinc oxide (usually 15-20%) to provide broad-spectrum SPF protection.
It’s applied in a sufficient amount (1/4 teaspoon for the face).
It’s reapplied every 2 hours when exposed to sunlight.
Potential Issues:
Serum-like sunscreens are often more lightweight, which can make people apply too little, leading to inadequate protection.
If it blends away too easily, you may not be getting the full SPF rating claimed on the bottle.
Who Should Use It?
Great for oily/combination skin or those who hate heavy sunscreen.
Works well as a daily SPF under makeup (if you aren’t in prolonged sun exposure).
Ideal for sensitive skin since it’s mineral-based and free of irritating chemicals.
Shop Kora
To ensure Silky Sun Drops 100% Mineral Sunscreen Serum provides full SPF 30 protection, apply at least 1/4 teaspoon (2 full drops) to dry skin after moisturizing, pat (don’t rub) for even coverage, let it set for 2-3 minutes before makeup, and reapply every 2 hours when exposed to sunlight.
3) Best for Dewy, Natural Glow: Well People Daygleamer Mineral Sunscreen Serum SPF 34 – $26
⭐ CCS: 8/10
💡 Pros: Lightweight serum texture, broad-spectrum SPF 34, leaves skin radiant and hydrated, clean ingredients, fragrance-free, reef-safe
⚠️ Deductions: Dewy finish may be too glowy for oily skin types, light coverage only
Well People’s Daygleamer Mineral Sunscreen Serum SPF 34 is a multitasking mineral sunscreen that doubles as a radiant base. Powered by non-nano zinc oxide, it delivers broad-spectrum protection while acting like a luminous skin tint that enhances your natural glow. Unlike many mineral sunscreens, Daygleamer feels more like a hydrating serum than a chalky SPF, and it layers seamlessly under makeup or on bare skin.
Formulated with skin-loving ingredients like jojoba oil, plant-derived squalane, and sunflower seed oil, it helps maintain moisture and softness throughout the day without clogging pores or feeling greasy. The slightly pearlescent finish gives a healthy sheen that dry and dull skin types will appreciate.
Shop Well People
While its glow-boosting effect is a bonus for most, those with oil-prone skin might find the dewy look too shiny by midday. And since it’s more of a skin enhancer than a full-coverage tint, don't expect it to cover imperfections. Still, for daily wear and no-makeup makeup lovers, this SPF-serum hybrid is a hidden gem in the clean beauty space.
4) Best for Lightweight Feel: Minori Daily Mineral Sunscreen - SPF 30 - $28
⭐ CCS: 8.5/10
💡 Pros: Lightweight, non-nano zinc oxide, dewy finish, no fragrance or essential oils
⚠️ Deductions: Lower SPF than ideal (30 instead of 50+), lacks antioxidants or additional skin-repairing actives
Minori’s sunscreen is a great choice for those seeking a gentle, minimalist, and clean mineral SPF, but it would be even better with a higher SPF and added skin-enhancing ingredients.
Shop Minori Daily Mineral Sunscreen
5) Best for Acne-Prone Skin: EltaMD d UV Glow Facial Suncreen, Tinted SPF 46 - $46
⭐ CCS: 9.8/10
💡 Pros: Niacinamide-infused, calms redness, fully invisible finish
⚠️ Deductions: Slightly lower zinc oxide percentage than some competitors
This dermatologist-favorite sunscreen contains 20.2% zinc oxide making it a hybrid option that blends perfectly into deeper skin tones without leaving a trace.
Shop Elta MD
6) Best for a Luminous Glow: Kinfield Sunglow Luminizing Facial Sunscreen Lotion, SPF 35 - $28
⭐ CCS: 9/10
💡 Pros: Lightweight, dewy finish, non-toxic formula, reef-safe
⚠️ Deductions: Lower SPF than some alternatives, may be too glowy for oily skin
Kinfield’s Sunglow Luminizing Facial Sunscreen is a game-changer for those who love a radiant, sun-kissed look without makeup. Unlike traditional sunscreens, it provides a sheer, golden tint that enhances the skin’s natural glow while delivering broad-spectrum SPF 35 protection. Made with non-nano zinc oxide, it’s reef-safe, fragrance-free, and free of endocrine disruptors—perfect for health-conscious skincare lovers.
Shop Kinfield
7) Best for Mattifying Finish: MDSolarSciences Mineral Crème SPF 50 - $46
⭐ CCS: 9.3/10
💡 Pros: Lightweight, mousse-like texture, reef-safe
⚠️ Deductions: SPF could be higher. This 100% mineral formula (2% zinc oxide) and Zinc Oxide 2% provides excellent protection while remaining completely invisible on dark skin.
Shop MDSolar
